The Cellar Project Review #1 - 2011 Oskar Blues Ten Fidy

Posted by: Stonecipher

Dec. 22, 2013

To kick off The Cellar Project we’ll begin with a beer that the majority of Americans can easily get their hands on any time of year, Oskar Blues Ten Fidy Imperial Stout.  This is not a “classic aging beer”, but it certainly fits the criteria; a big, boozy, rich, malty beer in a can.  The IBUs are much higher than most other age-able beers, but as we’ll see below, many of them are, surprisingly, still there.   

This is a beer that I very much enjoy when fresh, but I have never aged more than one year.  So I’m very excited to check this one out.  Here’s a few stats to start:

Location: Liquor Mart – Boulder, CO
Cost: $3.99

ABV: 10.50%

IBUs: 98

Brewery Location: Lyons, Colorado

Style: Russian Imperial Stout

Average Beer Advocate Rating: 4.37

Beer Advocate Score: 97 – World Class

My Original Beer Advocate Rating: 4.2

My Aged Rating: 4.1

Current Number of Reviews on Beer Advocate: 5,094

Brewery Description: Oskar Blues Ten Fidy

Canned On: 10/28/2011

Age at Time of Review: 2 years, 1 month, 4 days.

Electoral Votes for Distribution: 377 (415 w/ limited) Huh?  What’s this?

APPEARANCE:  (Original 3.5/Aged 4.0) When I read my BA review, I didn’t believe myself about how dark this thing was, but it is still not letting a single ray of light through.  Awesome.  The head is the color of coffee with a creamer or two added and about a half-inch of it has been resting atop this beer for the past ten minutes.  This is quite a spectacular display of head retention.  Plus the lacing is still solid, covering about 30% of the back of the glass.

SMELL:  (Original 3.5/Aged 4.5) Taking a sniff straight out of the can after it was popped provided a big, blast of straight up chocolate, and it was not straight dark chocolate, almost a blend of milk and dark.  Once this beer got in the glass, however, I see why I said it was just straight coffee last time.  It’s still there in full force, but now the other malt flavors seem to have developed in the can over the past two years, most notably, the chocolate and a nice dose of vanilla.  Also, for no reason at all, some dry oak seems to linger beneath the big, sweeter malts.

TASTE:  (Original 4.5/Aged 4.0) The coffee is still the dominating flavor, but it has changed.  The roastiness has most certainly mellowed, but somehow, the bitterness remains.  Oddly enough, and this is counter to all logic and reason here, but I am tasting hops in this beer that I never have previously; very grassy and bitter hops.  Some chocolate and vanilla are present, but not nearly to the same extent as they are in the nose.  A nice, subtle caramel flavor helps to round it all out.

MOUTHFEEL:  (Original 4.0/Aged 4.0) In spite of the impressive head retention, the carbonation has nearly vanished at this point; only a very subtle tickle reminds the palate that this is still beer.  The body is still big, but slightly thinner, and that light carbonation is a good fit for it.  Last time I said that this beer was smooth and oily – the smooth part is still very true, but I would not say oily at all, in fact, it seems a lot dryer. 

OVERALL:  (Original 4.5/Aged 4.0) Two years of aging this beer drastically improved the aroma, I really, really liked it a lot and it was far more complex than it was when fresh.  The taste is still outstanding, but as I already mentioned, it is a bit thinner and the body did not come through as strong as the nose did.  I was hoping that some of those chocolate and vanilla smells would have developed as nicely in the taste as well.

RECOMMEDED FOR AGING:  Yes, but...  If nothing else, it was worth a small investment just for the improvement in the nose.  Also, the can probably had a lot to do with the fact that, after two years, there is absolutely no sign of oxidization or skunking.  My complaint is that it does taste a bit thin for Ten Fidy and ultimately I do think it has lost a step from its fresh state, but many people will probably prefer it in the aged state.  Sadly, this was the only one I had aging.  I’d like to grab another 4-pack and let it sit for one year instead of two, I have a feeling that would be just about right for this one.

Oskar Blues Deviant Dale's India Pale Ale

Posted by: Tyler Rippeteau

Aug. 26, 2012

A beautiful case of Deviant Dale's

For a variety of reasons, this review of Oskar Blues Deviant Dale’s India Pale Ale is bound to be one of the most exciting I have ever done.  For starters, I am reviewing this beer on a train, hurtling across the great State of Nebraska at about 70 MPH in the middle of the night.  More importantly, though, I am reviewing this beer as a part of Reddit’s new beer blogging community’s (r/beerblogs) first ever community-wide review.  Check out everyone else’s reviews here.  So as we take a break from both The Avery Project and The Barleywine Project here at 20 Beers in 20 Nights, enjoy this review of a beer that is becoming a bit of an instant classic out here in Colorado. 

Deviant Dale’s has long been a favorite at the brewery in Lyons, CO.  Until earlier this year, however, it was not available outside the taproom.  So only those who could venture up into the tiny town outside of Boulder could taste this delicious brew.  Enter the new canning line at Oskar Blues (Longmont), one capable of producing tallboys at exceptionally high speeds, and bam!  We now have Deviant available just about everywhere Oskar Blues distributes.  Here are some stats:

Location: Somewhere near the Colorado/Nebraska border, on a train

Cost: $12.99/4-pack of tallboys

ABV: 8%

IBUs: 85

Brewery Location: Longmont, Colorado

Style: American IPA

Average Beer Advocate Rating: B+/3.99

My Beer Advocate Rating: A-/4.05

Current Number of Reviews on Beer Advocate: 381

Description: Oskar Blues Deviant Dale’s India Pale Ale

Glassware: Plain Pint Glass

Bottled On: NA

APPEARANCE:  (4 out of 5) A fairly strong pour into a pint glass reveals a nice, deep amber color with a generous off-white head.  The retention isn’t bad and the head seems to settle in for a little while after about half of it has evaporated.  At first the lacing is fairly thin and cathedral-like, but after pouring the remaining 4 ounces into my glass, it becomes much thicker, almost caked on.

SMELL:  (4 out of 5) Big pine and grapefruit aromas greet the nose with a hint of some woodiness.  The Deviant does not have a terribly complex smell, but it is strong, solid, appetizing and straight forward – typical for a big IPA like this.

TASTE:  (4 out of 5) Up front, the Deviant has a big dose of sweet caramel and toffee-flavored malt, along with a faint hint of chocolate.  Those malts vanish quickly, though, as a very strong hop flavor takes over.  At first the hops provide a piney and slightly weedy resinous taste, but towards the end of the sip they put forth a full-on lemon and grapefruit assault.  The switch from big malt to big hops really makes the hop bite seem much more pronounced than in other IPAs. 

MOUTHFEEL:  (4.5 out of 5) As you may have gathered from the previous paragraph, this beer starts out sweet and finishes very dry.  The hop bite at the end makes the middle part of the tongue feel almost raw, but the good news is that there is just enough malt in each new sip to repair it.  It flirts with the extreme, but never goes over the edge.  There is a mild boozy heat from the 8% ABV, but it only becomes noticeable as the beer warms.

OVERALL:  (4 out of 5) This beer is delicious as always.  I first tried this beer back before I moved to Colorado.  I was in Lyons specifically to go to the original Oskar Blues location.  In my initial review on Beer Advocate I noted that the malt up front was much sweeter and maybe even contained a hint of honey.  I didn’t get that honey this time and the malt does not seem to be as intense as it was back then.  Also, the hops seem a lot more aggressive, but either way, this is still a strong beer from a great Colorado brewery.